By Anton Lipkanou.
For too long, marketers have clung to the marketing funnel, blissfully unaware (or, in some cases, willfully ignorant) of the reality that today’s consumers follow a buying journey that doesn’t follow a funnel.
The days of casting wide nets with channel-first tactics are over. I believe that chief marketing officers who want their brands to be industry leaders must let go of the archaic strategies that once dominated their playbooks and instead focus their efforts on converting only the best of the best: their superfans.
The Downfall Of Traditional Marketing
Once celebrated for its simplicity, the marketing funnel model now falls short in mapping the intricate, non-linear journey of the modern consumer. It naively views the consumer journey as a straight shot from awareness to purchase, a concept laughably out of sync with the multifaceted, unpredictable nature of today’s consumer.
Despite the growing body of evidence pointing to the funnel’s obsolescence, the marketing world clings to it like a crutch. This reluctance to evolve is an ingrained mindset and a stubborn refusal to acknowledge that the game has changed. But the digital transformation doesn’t care about our comfort zones. Today’s consumers, armed with information and options, don’t just passively drift down a funnel. They’re active players, often sidestepping our best-laid marketing strategies.
In the third quarter of 2023, retail e-commerce sales saw the highest quarterly revenue in United States history—roughly $284 billion. As consumers increasingly turn to digital platforms, it becomes more important to adopt a more nuanced, consumer-centric marketing approach. Those who recognize this shift and move to strategies that engage with the evolving dynamics of consumer interaction can be the ones to capitalize on this historic surge in e-commerce activity.
Modern Marketing Challenges
Paid social media has aggressively expanded its influence past the top of the funnel, dramatically impacting a hallmark marketing metric: the cost per acquisition (CPA). The reliance on CPAs from these platforms has become a double-edged sword. Marketers putting all their eggs in the easy-to-measure paid social CPA basket have watched as costs skyrocket, leading to financial losses.
As we say goodbye to third-party cookies, marketers face a profound shift in data collection. Technology democratization has leveled the playing field, but this seismic shift comes with new challenges. Major digital platforms are increasingly pushing modeled data, which subtly encourages a dependency that could skew marketing decisions by driving reliance on convenient but inaccurate data. Thus, the real challenge for marketers is discerning the truth in a sea of approximations. The key lies in using this data judiciously, complementing it with other organic insights to ensure a grounded approach to understanding consumer behavior.
With a media inflation rate soaring past 5% (registration required), corporations demand efficiency. This can lead to significant compromises, not just in campaign quality but also in consumer engagement. Marketers must innovate and find ways to optimize budgets without sacrificing the long-term vision and engagement that fuel brand growth.
The Superfan Marketing Revolution
Superfan marketing is a strategic shift that prioritizes deep understanding and engagement with the real VIPs of the brand: superfans. In the post-cookie landscape, marketers are being called back to the basics: truly and profoundly understanding their consumers, brand positioning and product-market fit.
Gone are the days when marketers could lean on broad data to attribute impressions across the conversion funnel. Now, the game demands marketing that doesn’t just reach people but persuades them. While this approach demands more focus and effort, I believe it’s the only way a brand can win in this new era of marketing.
Creating A Supercycle
These superfans, the most engaged and loyal customers, are at the heart of this approach. Putting prospective superfans at the forefront of marketing strategies is about investing resources to delve into the depths of what makes them tick. This means understanding their specific needs, preferences and behaviors and then tailoring your messaging and strategies to resonate with their unique consumer DNA. Here’s how:
1. Leverage data to identify and engage potential superfans.
Re-imagine the traditional marketing funnel. Instead of looking at the funnel horizontally by stages, slice the funnel vertically by audience segment and focus only on the superfans. This is not about creating generic customer experiences for anyone who might buy; it’s about crafting personalized journeys that speak directly to the needs and preferences of your superfan segment. The goal here is to create a high-spend, high-value experience to nurture these prospects with such precision and care that they evolve into loyal, high-value customers.
2. Break down the silos between data, media and technology.
Data, media, and technology need to collaborate within your organization to ensure that the data insights inform media planning and technology deployment. But it doesn’t stop there. You must also optimize continuously. Analyze the effectiveness of your strategies and tactics in real time, using data and feedback to refine and adjust your approach.
3. Focus on strategic effectiveness.
Traditional marketing lives by the mantra “every prospect has value,” but this couldn’t be further from the truth. I believe distractors need to be cut from your attention completely. The core middle—the 80% of your customers who provide a decent amount of revenue but are not loyal to your brand—is not worth the resources required to figure them out. To make a real, material difference, focus your marketing only on your superfans.
Now is the moment to evaluate your marketing strategies. By stepping away from the outdated marketing funnel and embracing superfan marketing, savvy CMOs can write the playbook for the future.
Feature Image Credit: GETTY
By Anton Lipkanou.
Follow me on LinkedIn. Check out my website.
Anton Lipkanou is President / Partner at Delve Partners. Read Anton Lipkanou’s full executive profile here.
