Tag

Rejecting Social Media

Browsing

By Esha Chhabra

Can a brand exist in the modern era without social media, or even with less social media? It’s often touted as the go-to option for guerrilla marketing, and founder-led Instagram accounts have been key to building newer brands. The UK-based personal care brand, Lush, however, is taking a different route.

This month, more than 700 students at UC Berkeley stopped scrolling and smelled the roses. Literally. In the first 90 minutes of Lush’s “Stop Scrolling and Smell the Roses” activation, hundreds of students put down their phones to take part in a real-world experience built around the cosmetics brand’s Safer Socials campaign. The following day, Lush hosted tech executives and activists in Oakland for a conversation about a brighter tech future.

Rejecting Social Media

It is a striking scene for a company that five years ago walked away from Instagram, Facebook, TikTok and Snapchat entirely (they’re still on LinkedIn). In 2021, Lush announced it was quitting social media over concerns about the platforms’ effects on mental health, particularly for young people. At the time, the move looked like corporate self-sabotage. Brands were told they needed to post every day, if not multiple times a day, to stay relevant. Lush decided to find out what happens when you stop.

Five years later, the company’s head of marketing, Julia Hamfelt, says the bet paid off.

The decision had been building since 2019, when Lush began reducing its social media use over online safety and data privacy concerns. Then came the Facebook Files, the 2021 leak by whistleblower Frances Haugen documenting the company’s internal research on the harm its platforms caused, particularly to teenage girls.

“The findings leaked in Frances Haugen’s Facebook Files confirmed our worst fears, particularly about social media’s harmful impact on young girls, who make up a significant portion of our customer base,” Hamfelt says. “We couldn’t justify engaging with our community on these platforms knowing the dangers they posed. Staying true to our values required stepping away, even when that meant challenging conventional industry thinking.”

The numbers since then tell a more complicated story than the skeptics predicted. Hamfelt is candid that the exit had a cost. “It would be inaccurate to suggest that leaving major social media platforms hasn’t had an impact.”

But the company redirected its energy into channels it owns. Its app now has 2.8 million users, around 50% of whom opt-in to push notifications. Its global email newsletter has more than 6 million subscribers, she reports. And its Lush Club loyalty program offers early access to products and points on purchases.

She goes on to note that it’s actually not been harmful to the company’s business at all. “Despite our step away from major social media platforms, our retail traffic is up 26.6% compared to 2021 and growing every year.”

“Five years later, we’ve learned that leaving major social platforms doesn’t mean losing our community,” Hamfelt says. “Given how the conversation around social media has evolved over the last five years, from algorithms to data privacy concerns, we are more confident than ever that our decision to step away from these platforms was the right one.”

Should Other Brands Go Off Social Media

Not everyone is convinced the Lush playbook travels. Tori Dunlap, the financial educator behind Her First $100K, has built a business on the opposite bet. With 6 million followers across platforms, she is blunt about what social media did for her: “I started this company with $40 and a blog nobody read, and TikTok got it in front of millions of people. I couldn’t have paid for that, not only because I was broke, but because organic reach was so much more valuable than anything I could have paid for.”

Asked point blank whether a business can be built without social media today, her answer is short: “You can, but I wouldn’t. Social is still the easiest free distribution a small business has.”

But Dunlap draws a sharp line between using social media and depending on it. “The pressure to build a personal brand is real, and honestly mostly fair,” she says. “Where it goes wrong is when the platform becomes the whole business. You don’t control the algorithm, and an account can lose its reach or get taken down overnight.”

Her solution is the same one Lush landed on: own the relationship. “I treat social as the top of the funnel, where strangers find you, and the goal is getting them somewhere you own.”

For Dunlap, that somewhere is an email list. In April 2021, a single TikTok telling viewers to “take the quiz in our bio” brought in 100,000 email subscribers in a week, with no ad spend. The list now tops half a million. Her rule, she says, is “be useful first, then sell. Serve before you sell.”

On the question of whether creators are building on borrowed land, she is unsparing. “What’s breaking down is having a following with nothing behind it. That’s who I see quietly going back to corporate jobs. You need to be building a business, not a following.”

Dunlap respects Lush’s exit even as she declines to copy it. “I get why they did it. Walking away from that much reach on principle takes guts,” she says. “If I didn’t have to be on social media, I wouldn’t be.”

The caveat, she notes, is scale. “Lush operates in 48 countries and has been around since the nineties, so people know where to find them. If you’re a one-person shop, social might be the only way anyone hears about you.”

Does This Offline Approach To Social Media Work For Small Businesses

Hamfelt pushes back on the idea that only legacy brands can pull this off. “It’s not a one-size fits all approach, but you don’t need to be an established brand to reduce your dependence on social media,” she says. “A younger brand needs to evaluate what kind of relationship they want to have with their customers and build their marketing strategy to reflect this.”

Both women agree on the same test. Dunlap puts it this way: “I don’t think most should quit. But I’d want every brand to be able to, if that makes sense. If losing Instagram tomorrow wouldn’t sink you, you’re in a much better spot than if it would.”

Hamfelt makes the parallel case from the brand side. “There is definitely an assumption that being constantly visible is the same as being relevant, but it’s worth it for brands to question whether they’re truly building a meaningful relationship with their audience that way. Ultimately, relevance is offering something valuable as opposed to simply showing up everywhere. Consumers don’t need an endless stream of content to feel connected to your brand, they need a clear reason to trust you.”

And the offline world, both suggest, is having a moment. Hamfelt says Lush has “noticed a significant and rapidly growing appetite for experiences that bring people together in person, particularly when so much of our communication happens through screens.”

The Berkeley turnout is her evidence. “Ultimately, we want to give people a reason to step away from their screens, engage with their surroundings, and connect with one another.”

Five years ago, Lush’s exit looked like a protest. In 2026, with regulators circling, algorithms under fire and even the platforms’ biggest winners building backup plans, it looks less risky. The attention economy is less likely to disappear overnight, but the return on investment for brands maybe offline just as much as it has been online in recent years.

Feature image credit: Lush

By Esha Chhabra

Sourced from Forbes