Share

By Emily Steele

I have this same conversation with brands over and over again. They want more content, faster, and for it all to look really good. Every single time, I have to break the news to them: That’s not what’s working right now.

It’s not that AI hasn’t made content easier to make. It’s that consumers have gotten a lot better at identifying what’s real and a lot less forgiving of brands that don’t come across authentically.

The creator economy was estimated to be around $250 billion globally in 2023, and Goldman Sachs has predicted it will grow to $480 billion by 2027.

As the creator industry continues to scale, so does AI, and the result is consumer fatigue. Just 26% of consumers now say they prefer AI-generated creator content over traditional creator content, compared to 60% in 2023. Even 26% feels high given how quickly AI has infiltrated nearly every aspect of our lives without our explicit consent.

Consumers want real content from real people.

Consumers say they are more likely to trust a creator who isn’t always selling to them (29%), who shows real expertise (26%) or who relates to their demographic or hobbies (26%). Personal stories are the content type that people enjoy the most (44%), compared to product reviews and advice (40%).

I saw this happen this back-to-school season when a creator on our platform dropped a Reel that looked more like it was meant for her friends than the featured brand. It wasn’t the most highly-produced piece of content, but it was perhaps the most relatable.

It’s not just a brand problem; it’s an industry problem.

Consumers aren’t boycotting creators. Consumers are boycotting content that feels fake, and while they’re getting much better at spotting inauthentic content, AI makes it way harder to distinguish the difference. Among Americans, 76% say it’s “important to be able to tell if pictures, videos and text were made by AI or people,” but 53% aren’t confident that they could actually differentiate. Low-quality AI video accounts for about one-fifth of what a new account is served on YouTube alone.

Mark Zuckerberg has called this the “third phase“ of social media. After friends and family content and then creator content, AI-generated media is now pouring in as a massive new layer on top, and platforms haven’t adjusted. A Washington Post analysis found just one in eight major social media platforms clearly label AI-generated content. On the other hand, even a hedge like Meta’s “likely created or modified with AI” can hurt creator credibility, whether or not it’s accurate.

But platforms are starting to move. Snapchat “will no longer recommend wholly AI-generated videos on its Spotlight feed,” instead rewarding authentic creativity. Companies like LinkedIn and Substack have taken similar actions to identify AI-generated content. This is a positive step for the industry, but the landscape remains rocky for brands that are navigating how to reach their audience in a genuine way.

Brands and creators can meet in the middle.

Brands often approach creators with very prescriptive briefs because it can feel risky to work with an outside voice. But creators have spent years building their following, their voice and their tone, and audiences are often turned off when content feels over-scripted.

The sweet spot is actually meeting in the middle, where the brand gets the strategy and the guardrails, but the creator gets enough freedom to make it feel like it’s native to their voice. That’s what resonates most with people and can actually lead to sales.

Brands need a new scorecard.

Most brands are scoring creator marketing wrong. They want the safest number to put in a deck, and that’s follower count—but that’s actually a weak indicator of what will happen next. Views mean people scrolled by. That’s not the same as taking action. People don’t buy something just because they saw it once. It’s more nuanced than that. They buy because they trusted someone—a friend, a family member, a local voice—who introduced them to the product and made it feel like it could be part of their world.

That’s the through line here: The old scorecard rewarded reach, and the new scorecard rewards relevance. In practice, that means picking creators who align with your values over the ones with the biggest audience, weighting engagement over impressions and recognizing that a smaller, trusted voice can still have a big impact.

The future is for brands who build trust, not content.​

At my organization, we’re not anti-AI. But we’re not pro-AI. That’s our truth right now. I think more brands will land in the same place. AI is genuinely helpful for the type of work that’s happening behind the scenes. It’s not a substitute for the relationship between a creator and the people who trust them.

So the test I would apply to your next brief is this: Before you spec out deliverables, ask yourself if you’re giving the creator enough freedom to sound like themselves or if you’re making another polished ad that you’re hoping people will believe. That one decision may do more for your brand than any amount of additional content ever could, especially in a feed that’s increasingly crowded with content few people trust.​

Feature image credit: getty

By Emily Steele

Sourced from Forbes

Write A Comment